Conclusion and further work

Warning View the most recent version.

Archived Content

Information identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards and has not been altered or updated since it was archived. Please "contact us" to request a format other than those available.

This study presented upper bound estimates of the underground economy that could be missing from official GDP in Canada from 1992 to 2011. The estimates make use of strong, but plausible, assumptions on the potential magnitude of UE activity in the economy. As such, they provide an indication of the extent to which UE activity impacts the macroeconomic aggregates for each of the three measures of GDP: income, expenditure, and industry.

The estimates indicate that UE as a share of the official GDP has been quite stable in the last decade. It also indicates that UE is concentrated in certain categories of spending and in certain industries.

This study introduces several improvements. Estimates are now more timely, and include adjustments for the effects of inflation and are based on the revised CSNA 2012 framework that reflects the international SNA 2008 guidelines.

One purpose of this study was to assess the quality of the official estimates produced by Statistics Canada. It finds that at most the GDP could be understated by 2.3% and that incorporating UE in official estimates would not change significantly the overall growth pattern of the economy.Note1

There are other applications for this type of study. For instance, it may be used as a starting point for specialized studies on specific underground activities and sensitivity analysis of the various assumptions and approaches taken in this field of work.

In terms of future work, there are several avenues to explore. Among them, expanding this study to a provincial and territorial basis would be both useful for Statistics Canada and respond to requests from users. Regarding national level estimates, several avenues may be explored in the future. First, methodologies for specific portions of UE, especially the household spending expenditures could be improved. Second, it would be useful to clarify with more precision what portion of UE is already accounted for in the official estimates. Such a study would provide useful information for policy analysis as well as for examining the accuracy of official GDP estimates. Third, an avenue to explore is the sensitivity of UE estimates to the various data sources, methods and assumptions made. Fourth, the scope of the analysis could be expanded to examine in more detail UE spending on copyrights, software piracy, internet trade, prostitution or illegal drugs. Finally, further work could be carried to explore the possibility of expanding the industry information to a more disaggregated level.


Note

  1. It is worth noting that it is difficult to assess the impact of UE on overall growth during period of recession since there are only a few comparison points.
Date modified: