Table 1
Gentrification measures in the GENtrification, Urban INterventions and Equity (GENUINE) tool for Canadian census metropolitan areas
Freeman | Ding | Grube-Cavers | Steinmetz-Wood | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Original measure | GENUINE adaptations | Original measure | GENUINE adaptations | Original measure | GENUINE adaptations | Original measure | GENUINE adaptations | |
Gentrifiable (2006) | ||||||||
Spatial areas | Census tracts in central cities in the United States | Census tracts in all Canadian census metropolitan areas (CMAs) | Census tracts with 50+ people and housing units in the United States | Census tracts in all Canadian CMAs | Census tracts in Vancouver, Toronto, Montréal | Census tracts in all Canadian CMAs | Census tracts in Montréal | Census tracts in all Canadian CMAs |
Gentrification eligibility criteria | 1. Median income below 40th percentile of the metropolitan area | 1. Median household income < median for the CMA | Median income below the median for the city | Median household income < median for the CMA | 1. Average family income < CMA average | No adaptation | 1. Z-score median household income < 0 | No adaptation |
2. Proportion of housing built ≤ 20 years was below 40th percentile of the metropolitan area | 2. Proportion of housing built since 1990 < median for the CMA | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | 2. Number of college degree holders per capita < CMA average | No adaptation | 2. Z-score university degree holders < 0 | No adaptation | |
Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | 3. Z-score average renting costs < 0 | No adaptation | |
Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | 4. Z-score low-income households < 0 | No adaptation | |
Gentrified (2016) | ||||||||
Income | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Increase in family income > CMA average | No adaptation | Z-score difference (from 2006 to 2016) in median household income > 0 | No adaptation |
Education attainment | Increase in college graduates is greater than that for the metropolitan area | Increase in university degrees > median for the CMA | Increase in college-educated residents above the median for the city | Increase in university degree holders > median for the CMA | Increase in proportion of degrees per capita > CMA average | Increase in proportion of university degree holders > CMA average | Z-score difference in university degree holders > 0 | No adaptation |
Housing | Increase in real housing prices | Increase in housing value > median for the CMA | Increase in gross rent or median home value above median for the city | Increase in housing value > median for the CMA or increase in renting costs > median for the CMA |
1. Increase in average monthly rent > CMA average | No adaptation | Z-score difference in average renting costs > 0 | No adaptation |
Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | 2. Increase in proportion of owner-occupied dwellings > CMA average | No adaptation | Note .: not available for any reference period | Note .: not available for any reference period | ||
Age | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Z-score for proportion of adults aged 30 to 44 > 0 | No adaptation |
Occupation | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Increase in proportion of people professional occupations > CMA average | No adaptation | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable |
Poverty | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Note ...: not applicable | Z-score difference in proportion of low-income households < 0 | No adaptation |
. not available for any reference period ... not applicable Note: CMA = Census metropolitan area. Source: GENtrification, Urban INterventions and Equity (GENUINE) tool. |
- Date modified: