Statistics Canada - Statistique Canada
Skip main navigation menuSkip secondary navigation menuHomeFrançaisContact UsHelpSearch the websiteCanada Site
The DailyCanadian StatisticsCommunity ProfilesProducts and servicesHome
CensusCanadian StatisticsCommunity ProfilesProducts and servicesOther links

Warning View the most recent version.

Archived Content

Information identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards and has not been altered or updated since it was archived. Please "contact us" to request a format other than those available.

63F0022XIE

Distributive Trades Division

retail.jpg

CHANGES IN THE OUTPUTS OF ANNUAL RETAIL TRADE SURVEYS

Augustine Akuoko-Asibey

January 2001

I.  Introduction

Statistics Canada’s annual retail trade surveys1 are undergoing changes. Two activities underlie these changes. The re-design of our annual retail trade statistical program is one. The other is the conversion from the 1980 Standard Industrial Classification (1980 SIC) to the North American Industrial Classification System (NAICS). These activities will have significant impacts on the output of the annual surveys.

This paper has two goals. The first is to inform retail store data users, industry analysts, trade associations and other stakeholders of  these changes. The second is to consult with stakeholders on possible data outputs resulting from the changes.

The paper is organized into five parts. Following the introduction, Part II describes the outputs from the current surveys and compares and contrasts the current outputs with the new. Part III focuses on the introduction of NAICS codes and the changes in coverage for retail trade. In Part IV, the benefits resulting from the above changes are outlined. The final part (Part V) seeks comments or suggestions from data users, retail trade associations and industry specialists on the release of data products as a result of the changes to the surveys.


II Changes in Data Products

1. Output of current surveys

Statistics Canada currently has two publications as part of its annual retail trade survey program: Retailing in Canada (formerly known as Wholesaling and Retailing in Canada) Catalogue #63-236-XIB; and Retail Chain and Department Stores, Catalogue #63-210-XIB. The Retailing in Canada publication covers all retail trade, with the exception of direct selling. The major contents of this publication are number of locations, total operating revenue, operating expenses including the cost of goods sold, employee earnings and benefits, and gross margins. These variables are cross-classified using industrial breakdowns known as trade groups and also by province and territory. There are also data on total operating revenue for each SIC industry and additional details for chain and independent stores 2.

The Retail Chain and Department Store publication covers a subset of store retailers, that is, retail chains3 . The chains publication contains a much wider variety of tables than does Retailing in Canada. There are detailed tables on chains by number of stores, by sales level, and by industry. Since store size, in terms of floor area, is also requested on the questionnaire, there is detailed information, by industry, on sales per square foot or per square metre. There is also information on the number of chain stores and sales, by industry, for very large cities (Census Metropolitan Areas) as well as cities down to populations as low as 10,000. There is also a separate set of tables for Department Stores.

2. Output of the new surveys

As of the 1999 survey year, there will be significant changes to the products released from the annual surveys. Depending on the quality of responses, Statistics Canada hopes to be able to release data on retail franchise stores4. This is in addition to products on chain stores and independent stores.

The new surveys will provide expanded information for the three types of organizations, compared with pre-1999 surveys. For example, there is the possibility of providing adetailed breakdown of purchased service expenses into rental and leasing expenses, telephone and other communication expenses, insurance premiums etc. Additional financial data could be made available at the location level for all three business organizations. Moreover, independents and franchises will also have more location information at the company level, in addition to data on gross leasable area of premises.

III. NAICS and changes to the Retail Trade Industry

1. The new classification system

The second activity affecting the annual retail trade surveys is the introduction of a new industrial classification. Statistics Canada is in the process of converting the1980 Standard Industrial Classification (SIC) system to present statistical information using NAICS5. NAICS is the first-ever uniform system of North American industry classification. Created against the background of the North American Free Trade Agreement, it is designed to provide common definitions of the industrial structure of the three countries (Canada, United States and Mexico) and a common statistical framework to facilitate the analysis of the three economies. NAICS Canada replaces the 1980 SIC6.

2. NAICS and changes to the retail trade industry

The retail trade sector has been restructured under NAICS to reflect the changing nature of the retail industry in Canada. Under NAICS, a firm is classified as a retailer if it primarily engages in retailing merchandise, generally without processing, and rendering services incidental to the sale of merchandise. The new classification system identifies fewer industries that contribute to today’s retail trade economy; four less than 1980 SIC (from 73 1980 SIC industries to 69 NAICS industries). For store retailers7, the necessary and sufficient condition in the new classification system is the operation of a store, with the exception of heavy-duty truck dealers and farm equipment suppliers.

With NAICS, some new industries have been separately recognized for the first time in the retail trade sector. These new industries are convenience stores, gas stations with convenience stores and food (health) supplement stores. The new industries reflect recognizable parts of 1980 SIC divisions.

3. Cross-sector movements in retail resulting from conversion to NAICS

There are important differences in the retail sector, as classified using NAICS rather than SIC 1980. First, some store formats, previously classified to wholesale trade, are moving to retail trade. They include building material stores, computer and software stores, and office supply stores. Areas where the principal activity is repair, rather than selling merchandise, are moving from retail trade to the services sector. The primary area affected is automotive repair including garages not selling gasoline, paint and body repair shops, muffler replacement shops, motor vehicle glass replacement shops and motor vehicle transmission repair and replacement shops. In addition, areas where the principal activity is processing rather than selling merchandise are moving to manufacturing. Examples include dressmakers, tailors, and some bakeries.

Activities related to electronic shopping (e-commerce) are included in the Annual Non-Store Retail  survey, if they are conducted in an establishment where the principal activity is electronic commerce.

4. Dealing with data breaks or historical continuity of data

It is proposed to backcast total operating revenue by NAICS industry for 1998. This will be done through a retabulation of the micro-records already collected on a SIC 1980 basis. Bearing in mind the resources required to do this type of work and the level of demand, Statistics Canada would like to hear from users regarding their requirements for data continuity.

IV. Benefits to users of the new surveys and NAICS

1. Benefits of the new survey data

Statistics Canada expects that data from the new surveys will be of much more benefit to the retail industry. First, the new classification system is an update of the retail trade sector and individual industries to reflect appropriate coverage for today's and hopefully tomorrow's reality for retail. As such, business leaders and trade associations will recognize that it is more appropriate and relevant to today’s economy than SIC 1980.

Second, because of a common classification system, NAICS will allow for an international comparison of the performance of the retail sectors for Canada, the United States and Mexico, at least in terms of industries.

Third, with the proposed integration of the chains and retail stores components, there will be detailed information on locations for all retail stores. Such information is good not only  for benchmarking but also for studying the evolving structure of the Retail Trade Industry in terms of store size.

Fourth, the detailed location information will enhance the expenditure information from the surveys. For example, retailers can compare the expenditure patterns on energy and water expenses for similar organizations located in a mall or on the street.

Fifth, the results from the new survey will allow a better portrayal of the organizational structure of store retailers: chain stores, independent retailers and franchise operators. This will enable retailers to assess the financial performance of the industry by type of organization.

Sixth, our current paper method of publishing annual data was adopted in the era before the widespread use of diskettes, CD-ROMs and the Internet. Users of the new survey data will have the opportunity to take advantage of electronic dissemination rather than our current paper method.

2. Further benefits from the retail chain survey

In addition to the above benefits accruing to the retail store industry, there are other specific benefits that will accrue from the chain survey data. Data from the new retail chain survey can be used for benchmarking, or to compare a firm's revenue, expenses and financial ratios with averages for its type of retail chain. In addition, retailers may be able to assess their market share using chain sales data for small geographic areas. Moreover, retailers will be able to assess the efficiency of various types of chain stores in Canada, through sales per square meter or square foot data.

V. Consultations on data release

The preceding text has highlighted the changes to the annual retail trade surveys. Much of the content and especially the organizational structure and location detail result from previous consultations with retailers and are designed with the needs of the Private Sector in mind. It is hoped that these data will be useful in tracking the evolution of retail trade in Canada and in allowing individual retailers to benchmark their performance against industry averages for similar types of operations.

We anticipate integrating into a single product, the output from the retail store and retail chain surveys. It may not be possible to fully develop products for the 1999 data. However, there are a lot of possibilities for new types of presentations. It is the users and potential users of these data who are in a position to inform us of what would make the best output products. Your ideas and suggestions would be appreciated.

For further information on the annual retail chain and other retail store surveys, copies of questionnaires or comments and suggestions, write to:

Augustine Akuoko-Asibey
11D6 Jean Talon Building
Distributive Trades Division
Statistics Canada
Ottawa, ON
K1A 0T6
Email: [email protected]
Fax: (613) 951-3522


References

1The retail trade industry, under the 1980 Standard Industrial Classification, is divided into two main components: traditional store retailers, and direct sellers. The annual retail trade surveys for reference year 1998 reference year cover only traditional store retailers.

2Independent retailers generally operate less than 4 locations.

3A Retail Chain is defined as an organization operating four or more retail outlets in the same industry class under the same legal ownership, at any time during the survey year.

4A franchise is a person, group of persons, partnership or incorporated company granted a contractual privilege permitting the sale of a product, use of a trade name or provision of a service within a specified territory and/or in a specified manner.

5The North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) was developed by Statistics Canada, the Economic Classification Policy Committee of the United States Office of Management and Budget, and Mexico's Instituto Nacional de Estadistica, Geografia e Informatica (INEGI).

6The first Canadian SIC system was developed in 1948. Subsequent improvements led to revision in 1960, 1970 and 1980.

7The retail trade sector comprises two main types of retailers, that is, store and non-store retailers. Their main characteristics are different. Store retailers operate fixed point-of-sale locations, located and designed to attract a high volume of walk-in customers. Non-store retailers reach customers and market merchandise with methods such as, the broadcasting of infomercials, the broadcasting and publishing of direct-response advertising, the publishing of traditional and electronic catalogues, door-to-door solicitation, in-home demonstrations, temporary displaying of merchandise (stalls) and vending machines.


This article was written by Augustine Akuoko-Asibey.  Augustine  is a Program Manager in Distributive Trades Division.

Further information on Retail Trade can be found in the publications Retailing in Canada (Catalogue 63-236-XIB), available annually for $26 per issue and Retail chain and department stores (Catalogue 63-210-XIB) available annually for $30 per issue.  Order these products and other Statistics Canada publications by telephone, dial 1-800-267-6677, by fax: 1-800-889-9734, or by Internet.

For more information about retail data, call the Marketing and Clients Services Section, Distributive Trades Division at (613) 951-3549 (Toll free) 1-877-421-3067 or by Internet: [email protected].   



Home | Search | Contact Us | Français Return to top of page
Date Modified: 2002-05-07 Important Notices