Survey Methodology
Authors’ response to comments on “Handling non‑probability samples through inverse probability weighting with an application to Statistics Canada’s crowdsourcing data”:
Some new developments on likelihood approaches to estimation of participation probabilities for non‑probability samples
by Jean-François Beaumont, Keven Bosa, Andrew Brennan, Joanne Charlebois and Kenneth ChuNote 1
- Release date: June 25, 2024
Abstract
Inspired by the two excellent discussions of our paper, we offer some new insights and developments into the problem of estimating participation probabilities for non-probability samples. First, we propose an improvement of the method of Chen, Li and Wu (2020), based on best linear unbiased estimation theory, that more efficiently leverages the available probability and non-probability sample data. We also develop a sample likelihood approach, similar in spirit to the method of Elliott (2009), that properly accounts for the overlap between both samples when it can be identified in at least one of the samples. We use best linear unbiased prediction theory to handle the scenario where the overlap is unknown. Interestingly, our two proposed approaches coincide in the case of unknown overlap. Then, we show that many existing methods can be obtained as a special case of a general unbiased estimating function. Finally, we conclude with some comments on nonparametric estimation of participation probabilities.
Key Words: Best linear unbiased estimation; Best linear unbiased prediction; Estimating equation; Population likelihood; Pseudo likelihood; Sample likelihood.
Table of contents
- Section 1. General remarks
- Section 2. A population likelihood approach and the method of Chen, Li and Wu (2020)
- Section 3. The method of Wang, Valliant and Li (2021) and Pseudo-ILR
- Section 4. The method of Elliott (2009) and ILR
- Section 5. A sample likelihood approach
- Section 6. A unified estimating function
- Section 7. Concluding remarks
- References
How to cite
Beaumont, J.-F., Bosa, K., Brennan, A., Charlebois, J. and Chu, K. (2024). Authors’ response to comments on “Handling non-probability samples through inverse probability weighting with an application to Statistics Canada’s crowdsourcing data”: Some new developments on likelihood approaches to estimation of participation probabilities for non probability samples. Survey Methodology, Statistique Canada, n° 12‑001‑X au catalogue, vol. 50, n° 1. Paper available at http://www.statcan.gc.ca/pub/12-001-x/2024001/article/00001-eng.htm.
Note
- Date modified: