Table 17
Refused legal aid applications by reason for refusal

Warning View the most recent version.

Archived Content

Information identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards and has not been altered or updated since it was archived. Please "contact us" to request a format other than those available.

Refused legal aid applications by reason for refusal
  Total 1 Financial ineligibility Coverage restrictions Lack of merit Non-compliance or abuse Other reasons 2
  number percent number percent number percent number percent number percent
Newfoundland and Labrador  
2005/2006 3,270 540 17 313 10 417 13 0 0 2,000 61
2006/2007 3,058 554 18 313 10 395 13 0 0 1,796 59
2007/2008 2,852 582 20 313 11 400 14 0 0 1,557 55
2008/2009 2,833 566 20 313 11 374 13 0 0 1,580 56
2009/2010 3,034 657 22 442 15 395 13 0 0 1,540 51
Prince Edward Island  
2005/2006 . . . . . .
2006/2007 . . . . . .
2007/2008 . . . . . .
2008/2009 . . . . . .
2009/2010 . . . . . .
Nova Scotia  
2005/2006 2,408 1,181 49 56 2 264 11 79 3 828 34
2006/2007 2,419 1,089 45 94 4 222 9 95 4 919 38
2007/2008 2,608 1,241 48 133 5 299 11 109 4 826 32
2008/2009 2,674 1,400 52 158 6 199 7 75 3 842 31
2009/2010 3,360 1,617 48 199 6 326 10 76 2 1,142 34
New Brunswick  
2005/2006 795 .. .. . .. 795 100
2006/2007 830 .. .. . .. 830 100
2007/2008 550 73 13 292 53 . 69 13 116 21
2008/2009 556 61 11 312 56 . 48 9 135 24
2009/2010 .. .. .. . .. ..
Quebec  
2005/2006 38,009 24,366 64 6,987 18 1,678 4 74 0 4,904 13
2006/2007 36,962 24,444 66 6,552 18 1,514 4 56 0 4,396 12
2007/2008 37,420 25,563 68 6,362 17 1,280 3 58 0 4,157 11
2008/2009 38,575 26,754 69 6,204 16 1,282 3 48 0 4,287 11
2009/2010 39,778 27,625 69 6,352 16 1,280 3 46 0 4,475 11
Ontario 3  
2005/2006 46,178 24,270 53 10,579 23 .. . 11,329 25
2006/2007 44,256 22,412 51 11,194 25 .. . 10,650 24
2007/2008 42,193 21,649 51 10,128 24 .. . 10,416 25
2008/2009 40,980 21,836 53 9,868 24 .. . 9,276 23
2009/2010 38,176 22,538 59 8,469 22 .. . 7,169 19
Manitoba 4  
2005/2006 3,612 396 11 235 7 749 21 17 0 2,215 61
2006/2007 5,025 675 13 431 9 802 16 21 0 3,096 62
2007/2008 6,142 728 12 356 6 740 12 54 1 4,264 69
2008/2009 6,378 724 11 321 5 874 14 60 1 4,399 69
2009/2010 7,353 888 12 446 6 1,084 15 114 2 4,821 66
Saskatchewan  
2005/2006 1,772 1,451 82 119 7 89 5 27 2 86 5
2006/2007 1,930 1,571 81 176 9 90 5 20 1 73 4
2007/2008 1,923 1,691 88 117 6 79 4 10 1 26 1
2008/2009 1,254 1,080 86 88 7 51 4 13 1 22 2
2009/2010 1,587 1,283 81 176 11 56 4 16 1 56 4
Alberta  
2005/2006 10,003 4,135 41 2,729 27 939 9 698 7 1,502 15
2006/2007 8,974 4,013 45 2,262 25 748 8 712 8 1,239 14
2007/2008 8,965 3,630 40 2,402 27 713 8 867 10 1,353 15
2008/2009 7,361 2,311 31 2,389 32 739 10 718 10 1,204 16
2009/2010 10,051 3,171 32 3,636 36 1,094 11 599 6 1,551 15
British Columbia  
2005/2006 11,174 2,382 21 5,192 46 . . 3,600 32
2006/2007 11,175 2,866 26 4,425 40 . . 3,884 35
2007/2008 11,233 3,221 29 3,824 34 . . 4,188 37
2008/2009 12,558 3,274 26 4,568 36 . . 4,716 38
2009/2010 14,112 2,965 21 6,537 46 . . 4,610 33
Yukon  
2005/2006 74 57 77 14 19 3 4 0 0 0 0
2006/2007 61 51 84 7 11 3 5 0 0 0 0
2007/2008 67 53 79 10 15 3 4 1 1 0 0
2008/2009 59 44 75 6 10 9 15 0 0 0 0
2009/2010 87 79 91 5 6 3 3 0 0 0 0
Northwest Territories  
2005/2006 485 129 27 33 7 88 18 230 47 5 1
2006/2007 484 130 27 33 7 46 10 230 48 45 9
2007/2008 406 66 16 27 7 68 17 215 53 30 7
2008/2009 264 82 31 28 11 78 30 55 21 21 8
2009/2010 .. .. .. .. .. ..
Nunavut 5  
2005/2006 64 3 5 30 47 15 23 1 2 15 23
2006/2007 46 15 33 27 59 4 9 0 0 0 0
2007/2008 .. .. .. .. .. ..
2008/2009 38 4 11 0 0 34 89 0 0 0 0
2009/2010 20 4 20 4 20 0 0 11 55 1 5
Total  
2005/2006 117,844 r 58,910 r 50 r 26,287 r 22 r 4,242 r r 1,126 1 27,279 r 23 r
2006/2007 115,220 r 57,820 r 50 r 25,514 r 22 3,824 r 3 1,134 1 26,928 r 23 r
2007/2008 114,359 r 58,497 r 51 r 23,964 r 21 3,582 r 3 1,383 1 26,933 r 24 r
2008/2009 113,530 r 58,136 r 51 r 24,255 r 21 r 3,640 r 3 1,017 1 26,482 r 23 r
2009/2010 117,558 60,827 52 26,266 22 4,238 4 862 1 25,365 22
1.
The refused application count does not include those who are denied services through pre-screening measures. Legal aid plans screen applicants to some degree before an application is filed.
2.
Other reasons for refusal may include, among others, client cancelled/abandoned, coverage cancelled, or duplicate application.
3.
Ontario has 79 legal aid clinics that are independent, non-profit organizations funded by the legal aid plan. Staff lawyers and community legal workers at these clinics provide legal aid services primarily in "other" civil matters, particularly in the area of poverty law which includes, social assistance/income maintenance, landlord and tenant, workers' compensation, criminal injuries compensation, and refugee and immigration matters. In 2009/2010, these clinics accounted for 52% of applications refused for financial ineligibility. Beginning in 2005/2006, counts for lack of merit are included in coverage restrictions.
4.
In 2005/2006, Manitoba began to issue one legal aid certificate per matter. This led to an increase in the count for total, approved and refused legal aid applications. In 2006/2007, the use of certificate equivalents initiated by staff was discontinued, resulting in a decrease in the count for total and approved applications and an increase in refused applications. In 2009/2010, Manitoba began to include the number of applications that were used to generate secondary or tertiary certificates in the total number of legal aid applications reported. This led to an increase in the count for total and approved legal aid applications.
5.
In 2009/2010, the capacity for statistical reporting in Nunavut was limited due to issues with information tracking systems. As a result, the number of refused applications may be underreported and are not comparable to previous years.
Note(s):
For more details on legal aid concepts and terminology please refer to the glossary.
Source(s):
Statistics Canada, Canadian Centre for Justice Statistics, Legal Aid Survey 3308.