![]() |
|
![]() | ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
Archived ContentInformation identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards and has not been altered or updated since it was archived. Please "contact us" to request a format other than those available. Wheels of change: Employment in Canada's trucking industry, 1988-1994Larry McKeown and Willa Rea
"If youve got it, a truck brought it."2 When you stop to think about it, an increasing number of the things we use are transported to market, for at least part of the way, by truck. The trucking industry is becoming increasingly important to the transportation sector of the Canadian economy. This growing importance can be attributed to several factors including the deregulation of transportation, the surge in trade with the United States and the evolving structure of the industry itself. It is within this context that concern for labour issues, including a driver shortage, has been voiced.3 The demands on drivers have increased, driver training is inadequate and, as a result, there is a perceived shortage of qualified drivers. This study examines employment in the trucking industry from 1988 to 1994 by looking at various sources of employment data at Statistics Canada. The paper begins by describing the political, economic and management issues affecting trucking in Canada. Export-based economic growth and the deregulation of the transportation industry, combined with modified business practices, have brought about significant change in the trucking industry. For example, trucking activity now reflects shippers requirements for "just-in-time" delivery systems and a higher level of client service. Such service can include a range of logistical activities such as distribution, warehousing and inventory management. Truck drivers are required to work within this rapidly changing environment. The article continues with an overview of the employment situation in trucking based on Statistics Canadas Survey of Employment, Payroll and Hours (SEPH). Next, the "demand" for drivers by carriers is examined in more detail using data from the Motor Carrier of Freight (MCF) survey of for-hire trucking firms (see Chapter 2 for the results of this survey). In addition, pertinent details such as driver age, education, and experience, from Statistics Canadas Labour Force Survey (LFS) are used to learn more about truckers themselves (the "supply" side of trucking employment). Data gathered from carriers about truckers (the MCF data) are used as a surrogate for the demand for truck drivers. Data gathered from truckers about themselves (the LFS data) are used as a surrogate for the supply of truckers. Looking at the employment issue from these two perspectives provides greater detail. Using different data sources provides an opportunity for trends to be confirmed and for inconsistencies to be explored.
1. Highlights The highlights of the funding are as follows:
2. The Canadian Trucking Industry 2.1 The Regulatory Environment The following changes to the regulatory environment of the trucking industry have taken place during the study period:
It appears that the only trucking regulations to remain will be those emphasizing safety and those concerning drivers and equipment.4 2.2 The Economic Context When the MVTA took effect in 1988, the Canadian economy was entering the last two years of a growth trend that had started in the early 1980s; trucking activity expands and contracts due to changes in the economy with about a six month time lag.5 After reaching a peak in 1989, the economy did not attain this same level of output again until 1993. (See Figure 1.) During the period of economic retrenchment in the early 1990s, many businesses responded by reducing expenditures. Trucking firms were no exception. More often than not, businesses targeted labour as the primary candidate for this expenditure reduction and the Canadian unemployment rate hovered above 10 per cent for most of this period. The unemployment rate for truckers between 1991 and 1993 averaged 15 per cent. Although recovery was tentative during the years 1992 and 1993, there was some improvement in both economic output and in the level of employment.
By 1994 the Canadian economy had surged ahead based largely on increasing exports, many of them to the United States. Both imports from, and exports to, the U.S. exceeded $100 billion in value during 1994. There was an accompanying increase in the level of trucking activity in that same year with trucks carrying 58 per cent of exports to, and 81 per cent of imports from, the United States.6 With the growth of the Canadian economy exceeding 4 per cent in 1994, trucking activity increased and the level of employment in the trucking industry began to rise. 2.3 An Evolving Industry Increased competition resulting from deregulation and from the recession of the early 1990s has had a lasting effect on the operating methods of the trucking industry. Despite more robust economic growth in 1994, the competition from American carriers and the competitive nature of a deregulated environment have caused the Canadian trucking industry to continue to add technical and operational innovations to their standard transportation services. For example, "just-in-time" delivery systems and improved inventory management mean that carriers have had to become more flexible and responsive to the needs of shippers. The advent of "track and trace" technologies and equipment leasing are evidence of this. This drive for competitive advantage through an improvement in client services means that more demands are placed on trucking industry employees, including truck drivers. Driving a truck should no longer be considered an unskilled occupation. This change was recognized in a 1990 study sponsored by Human Resources Development Canada, which assessed the human resource needs of the trucking industry. The study identified a pressing need for skills upgrading for existing drivers and was the impetus behind the creation of the Canadian Trucking Human Resources Council (CTHRC). Truck drivers are now becoming "logistics operators" with duties that may require some computer literacy. This is reflected in the increase in the percentage of trucking industry employees who have post-secondary education or training, from 6 per cent in 1988 to 20 per cent in 1994. In addition to the growing requirement for better educated truckers, demographic changes indicate that the segment of the Canadian population that provides new recruits to the trucking industry (those in their late twenties and early thirties) is declining in number. David Foot, economist and demographer, also suggests that, as the population ages, fewer persons are opting for a "life on the road" because of the long hours away from home.7 In short, while the demographic makeup of the Canadian population and the demands of an expanding economy are responsible for quantitative shifts in trucking employment, changing operational requirements are responsible for qualitative shifts. 3. The Data8 Three surveys were used in this study: Survey of Employment, Payroll and Hours (SEPH) Data from the Survey of Employment, Payroll and Hours (SEPH) are examined here to obtain an overview of the trucking industry in Canada. SEPH data are collected by Standard Industrial Classification (SIC). Therefore, data for owner operators are not included since they are classified as self-employed. SEPH data also exclude private trucking employment since this activity is classified to other industries (e.g., retail and manufacturing). Motor Carriers of Freight (MCF) Survey Data from the Motor Carriers of Freight (MCF) survey were examined to assess the demand for truck drivers by the trucking industry. The data from the MCF used in this study are for for-hire carriers having operating revenues of $1 million and over. Data for owner operators and private carriers are not included in this study. The 1994 MCF survey results are reported in Chapter 2 of this publication. Labour Force Survey (LFS) Data from the Labour Force Survey (LFS) provide information about the supply of truckers. This information is collected from a nationally representative sample of individuals reporting their occupation. Therefore, "truckers" includes salaried drivers and owner operators working for private and/or for-hire trucking companies. 4. Employment in Canadas Trucking Industry 4.1 An Overview This section examines SEPH data (1988-1994) for the number of employees and the weekly hours worked for three categories: the trucking industry, the transportation sector and the economy as a whole.9 Trucking industry employees not only include drivers, but also management, office and administrative help, and repair and maintenance crews. Since the number of employees in the economy as a whole is so much higher than in either of the other two categories, the 1988 values in Figure 2 were set to 100 and indices corresponding to the data were plotted for subsequent years. For all three categories, the number of employees followed the business cycle. That is, the number of employees fell during the recession of the early 1990s and has been gradually rising as the economy recovers. For none of the three groups has the number of employees reached pre-recession levels. The number of employees in the trucking industry fell off most sharply and has only come within 87 per cent of its employment peak of 151,000 persons in 1989. This contrasts with the number of employees in the transportation sector which came within 90 per cent of its 1990 peak of 481,000 and the number of employees in the Canadian economy which came within 93 per cent of its 1990 high of over 11 million. Those employed in trucking and in the transportation sector work longer hours, an average of 37 hours per week for those in trucking compared to an average of 31 hours for those employed in the economy as a whole. (See Figure 3.) The number of hours that the average Canadian worked in a week dropped by only 1.5 during the recession, but by 3 hours for truckers and 3.2 hours for workers in the transportation sector. The average number of hours worked in a week has not returned to its pre-recession high for any of the three categories. Possible explanations for the trucking category include the acquisition by the rail sector of a greater share of the long distance transportation market while truckers emphasized "same day return" transport routes and the increasing trend of truck drivers to work in pairs.
4.2 The Demand for Truckers Drivers made up 56 per cent of the total employment in trucking in 1988. By 1992, this had climbed to 58 per cent where it has remained. (See Figure 4.) The number of both drivers and employees followed the business cycle by declining during the recession and rising during recovery. However, unlike the number of trucking employees, the number of drivers has reached its pre-recession high, indicating that firms have become leaner by permanently cutting non-essential employees such as administrators and office help and retaining (and even hiring) drivers. This is part of the post-recession trend towards rationalizing business practices that has taken place throughout the Canadian economy.
Payments to owner operators have also risen over the study period to $2.6 billion from $2 billion in 1989. (See Figure 5.) The use of owner operators is a more flexible choice for trucking firms wanting to increase revenues without increasing their permanent payroll and investing capital in vehicles. If drivers and owner operators are considered together, the trucking industry appears to have considerably increased its number of drivers since the recession. The demand for truckers over the study period naturally fell during the recession. Increased operating revenues (from $8.8 billion in 1989 to $11 billion in 1994) indicate that business has improved for carriers recently, but examining the size of the increases in the number of drivers and the number of hours worked per week does not support this. This increase in the amount paid to owner operators helps to explain how trucking firms have been able to increase revenues without taking on more drivers or increasing their hours. Another explanation is that the sector is more efficient due to improved business practices such as the new softwares used for scheduling.
The average salary for employees in for-hire trucking firms having operating revenues of at least $1 million has increased to $33,000 in 1994 after averaging $31,000 between 1990 and 1993.10 (See Figure 6.) This indicates either a decline in the supply of qualified truckers or an increase in the demand for their services. Trucking firms are finally in a position to pay drivers a salary commensurate with the long hours, difficult conditions, and increased educational requirements of driving a truck in the 1990s.
4.3 The Supply of Truckers The employment rate depends on the education level of truckers. Figure 7 shows that, in 1988 and 1989, truckers with only a primary education had the highest employment rate. Between 1990 and 1993, it was truckers having a secondary education who had the highest employment rate. But by 1994, truckers having a post secondary degree, diploma, trades certificate or apprenticeship training were the most likely to be employed of the three educational groups. The number of truckers holding a diploma has risen since 1988 from 17,000 to 57,000. In contrast, the number of truckers with secondary or primary education has fallen during the same time period. Average job tenure figures declined during the recession indicating that drivers who had been with one carrier for a long time were laid off or retired. (See Figure 8.) As the recession faded, the average number of months that employed truckers had spent at their jobs rose as drivers who had held on to their jobs accrued more and more time. These drivers were less likely to switch employers during a time of high unemployment. The year 1994 shows a drop in the average number of months of job tenure. Possible explanations include the hiring of more drivers as business improves and the retirement of older drivers. The average age of truckers steadily increased from 36 years in 1988 to 38 in 1992 where it has remained.
Salaried drivers show less fluctuation in job tenure than self-employed drivers (owner operators). However, as expected, self-employed truckers have spent more time in their current job (an average of almost 8 years compared to around 6 years for salaried truckers). Generally, truckers in 1994 have spent less time in their current jobs (6.2 years) than truckers in 1988 (6.6 years). The number of hours truck drivers worked in a week is rising but has not reached pre-recession levels. Figure 9 shows the average number of hours worked per week for all employed truck drivers, broken down for salaried and self-employed truck drivers (owner operators). Not surprisingly, owner operators work longer hours than salaried truck drivers (53 hours compared to 51 hours in 1994) since they are under pressure to keep working to cover their fixed costs. Safety regulations allow truckers to drive no more than 15 hours at a stretch and no more than 60 hours in a week.11
5. Implications 5.1 The Demand for Truckers Clearly, the demand for truckers is increasing. Drivers make up a growing proportion of the work force in the trucking industry and, together with owner operators, are the backbones of the industry. Their salaries are rising, as are the expenditures of trucking firms on owner operators. In fact, the use of owner operators instead of in-house drivers allows the trucking industry to take advantage of the post-recession increase in business opportunities without adding permanently to its payroll expenditures. 5.2 The Supply of Truckers Unfortunately, while the demand for truckers has been increasing, their supply appears to be dwindling. Not only is this indicated in studies and articles documenting the increasing frustration of carriers searching for drivers (some of which are cited here), but the data also support this position. An example is the increase in the average salary of drivers, an indicator of their scarcity. In addition, the return of a strong economy has resulted in an increase both in the number of drivers and owner operators employed, and in the number of hours they work per week. The increase in both these variables at the same time is consistent with drivers being in short supply. The drop in the unemployment rate for truckers, from 16 per cent in 1991 to 11 per cent in 1994, also supports the notion of a shortage in the supply of truckers. While it has not decreased to the pre-recession level, the nature of trucking has changed so much since the late 1980s that it is reasonable to suppose that most truckers who want to work and who have the required skills have found jobs. The increase in the average age of truckers indicates that fewer new recruits are entering the field. Moreover, as the Canadian population (dominated by the baby boomers) ages, there are fewer people in the tradition labour pool to replace experienced, retiring driver. There is a tendency for drivers to retire early, at least from the more strenuous forms of truck driving12 and, traditionally, entry-level truck drivers have been white males in their late twenties and early thirties. Only 3 per cent of truck drivers are female and ethnic minorities are not as well represented as in the general population.13 The expansion of the traditional labour pool to include these two groups could improve the supply of truckers. In addition to this quantitative reason for the shortage, there may also be a qualitative reason. It could be that the current pool of drivers lacks the skills required in todays market. Even though the data show that truckers are better educated, driving a truck requires more complex skills that in the past. Drivers are required to handle anything from computer based routing systems to complex safety regulations, and also need good interpersonal skills for dealing with clients since they are considered to be company representatives. While the number of employed truckers having a post secondary degree, diploma, trades certificate or apprenticeship training increased by 43 per cent between 1990 and 1994, they represent only 20 per cent of all employed truckers and this may still not meet the requirements of carriers. In the opinion of some employers, not all driver training courses provide enough practical training in driving skills. Moreover, trucking firms, like firms in many other industries, are reluctant to invest in training because of training "leakage". In other words, there may be disincentive to provide in-house training since drivers can simply move, with their new skills, to competing firm.14 In short, the data support the anecdotal comments of industry players that there is a shortage of qualified drivers.14 This shortage is partly quantitative due to the reduction in size of truckings traditional labour pool - young, single men. The shortage is also partly qualitative in that the trucking industry now requires drivers with a different skill set. Regardless of the extent to which this shortage is quantitative or qualitative, the health of the trucking industry rides on the efforts of industry leaders to find a solution.
Endnotes
1 The authors would like to thank Michelle Simard (Household Survey Methods Division), Fred Barzyk (Transportation Division), and Patricia Liston (Survey Operations Division) for their contributions. 2 Price Waterhouse (1990), Canadian Trucking Industry: Human Resource Challenges and Opportunities, p. xiv 3 See "A chronic shortage of long-haul drivers sidelines trucks and may slow business" , in The Globe & Mails March 10, 1995 Report on Transportation and Logistics. Se also National Transportation Agency (1995), 1994 Annual Review, p. 111, "industry also responded in various ways to the continued driver shortage in certain market segments". 4 Woudsma, Clarence (1995) "North American Surface Freight Transportation: Policy Evolution and Evaluation" in Transport Planning and Policy Issues: Geographical Perspectives: Department of Geography, University of Waterloo. 5 National Transportation Agency (1995), 1994 Annual Review, p. 128. 6 Data from the International Trade Division, Statistics Canada 7 Ontario Trucking Association (1955), Truck News, Vol. 15, Issue 10. 8 A For-hire Carrier is any carrier which undertakes the transport of goods for compensation. Owner Operators own/lease one or more power units and provide hauling services under contract to for-hire or private carriers. A Private Carrier is a company whose principal occupation is not trucking and which maintains its own fleet of vehicles (owned or leased) for transporting its own freight. 9 The "economy as a whole" is represented by the industrial aggregate, defined by SEPH as the total of all industries surveyed by SEPH. Industrial Aggregate = Standard Industrial Codes 041-999. 10 In 1994, the figure for "average salary" from the MCF survey includes employee benefits that are valued at approximately 20 per cent of total salary. The value of $33,000 that appears above has been adjusted to exclude benefits so that it can be compared with data from the previous year. The actual value of the average salary (including benefits) for employees in for-hire trucking firms in 1994 is $40,000. 11 Price Waterhouse (1990), Canadian Trucking Industry: Human Resource Challenges and Opportunities, p. 86. 12 Price Waterhouse (1990), Canadian Trucking Industry: Human Resource Challenges and Opportunities, p. 84 13 Price Waterhouse (1990), Canadian Trucking Industry: Human Resource Challenges and Opportunities, p. 43. 14 Prentice, Barry E. (1995), "Transport/Logistics Education and Training: Planning for the 21st Century", dans Chartered Institute of Transport in Canada, October 1995, p.8.
|
|
|
|