Information identified as archived is provided for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. It is not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards and has not been altered or updated since it was archived. Please "contact us" to request a format other than those available.
Do Relative Canada/U.S. Prices Equate to the Exchange Rate?
By Ryan Macdonald
Start of text box
This Economic Insights article discusses price differences between Canada and the United States. It is based on the concepts and methods from Statistics Canada's Purchasing Power Parity program.
End of text box
Canada and the United States share one of the longest borders in the world, their economies are intertwined, and trade between them is extensive. Consequently, a widely held public expectation is that, after adjusting for the exchange rate, the prices of goods between the two countries should roughly equate.
The 'law of one price'
The postulate that prices for goods adjust between nations to reflect the exchange rate is the 'law of one price.' It states that consumers and businesses will move to arbitrage between markets so that the price of a good in Canada is equal to the price of that good in the United States multiplied by the exchange rate. However, the law of one price is seldom supported in practice, and may not apply when transportation costs are high relative to the value of the good or service, trade barriers exist, market participants have some form of market power, or for non-traded goods and services.
Moreover, the law of one price applies only to a single commodity. Consumers in Canada and the United States purchase thousands of goods and services, some of which are traded, some of which are not. To obtain a more appropriate measure for comparing U.S. and Canadian prices, it is necessary to combine information representative of all goods and services that consumers buy. This aggregate measure, referred to as a "Purchasing Power Parity," reflects differences in the overall price level between the United States and Canada.
Market exchange rates versus purchasing power parities
The U.S.–Canadian Purchasing Power Parity is an estimate of what the exchange rate would have to be to equate the purchasing power of the U.S. and Canadian currencies in final product markets. It is a hypothetical exchange rate based on observed prices. It can, and does, differ from the actual market exchange rate because the products Americans and Canadians consume are not the same as the products and commodities traded, and because the Purchasing Power Parity excludes financial asset prices that can influence market exchange rates.
The U.S.–Canadian Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate and the US$/CAN$ market exchange rate occasionally have similar levels, and can move in the same directions through time (Chart 1). Since 1970, they have been broadly equal in six periods: 1971/1972, 1977/1978, 1988/1989, 1992/1993, 2005/2006, and 2008/2009. In the remaining periods, however, the rates differed, sometimes substantially. Nonetheless, over time, they have been similar enough that the market exchange rate can be viewed as fluctuating around the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate.
In the early 1970s, the market exchange rate was as much as 10 cents higher than the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate. A subsequent reversal of positions brought the market exchange rate below the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate—as much as 10 cents lower in 1985/1986. By 1991, the market exchange rate had risen to 6 cents more than the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate, but then fell to create a 19-cent gap between the two in 2000/2001. The rapid appreciation of the Canadian dollar after 2002 eliminated the disparity by 2005/2006, and then pushed the market exchange rate 8 cents above the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate in 2010.
A common source of changes?
While deviations between the market exchange rate and the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate can last for several years, the fact that they repeatedly revert to similar levels suggests that they are both influenced by the same fundamental features of the U.S. and Canadian economic systems. It is beyond the scope of this paper to delve into what features are most important for determining the relative price level for the United States and Canada; however, economic theory suggests that product and industry mixes, trade patterns, productivity levels, and money supply are all possibilities.
The volatility of the market exchange rate compared with the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate is noteworthy. In the context of both rates being driven by the same economic forces, it is natural to ask if the market exchange rate adjusts more rapidly, and to a greater degree. Since 1970, Canada has maintained a floating exchange rate based on a fiat currency. This floating exchange rate adjusts as economic shocks from abroad are transmitted to Canada. The relative volatility of the market exchange rate and the relative stability of the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate suggest that the floating exchange rate has helped to absorb short-run shocks that would otherwise manifest themselves in final product prices.
Consumer goods, consumer services and the exchange rate
Purchasing Power Parity exchange rates are also produced at more disaggregated levels to facilitate comparisons of real expenditures on product groups between the United States and Canada. These disaggregated Purchasing Power Parity exchange rates can be used to reinforce two points.
First, the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rates for goods do not move in the same way as for services over time (Chart 2). The extent to which the market exchange rate deviates from the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate depends greatly on whether goods or services are examined. This result reflects differences in the ability of firms and consumers to arbitrage between markets. It also reinforces the necessity of using an overall measure of relative prices between the United States and Canada when assessing the degree to which the market exchange rate is over- or undervalued. Estimates based on particular products or product groups will not capture the nature of all expenditures between the two countries, and will not be able to adequately describe differences in their aggregate price levels.
Second, when the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rates for consumer goods and consumer services (as opposed to the overall Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate) are compared with the market exchange rate, the latter is still more volatile. The difference in volatility between the overall Purchasing Power Parity and the market exchange rate, therefore, does not appear to stem from rigidity in non-traded services prices.
Do U.S. and Canadian prices equate?
The Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate is an estimate of the exchange rate necessary to equate purchasing power between the United States and Canada for an overall bundle of final products. Since 1970, movements in the market exchange rate and the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate have been similar. At particular points in time, the two rates will be broadly equal, but these episodes are fleeting. In the short-term, market exchange rates and Purchasing Power Parity exchange rates can diverge considerably. The short-run responses of the market exchange rate place it in a position where it rarely conforms to the notion of equating the purchasing power of the two nations. Moreover, because the Purchasing Power Parity exchange rate is based on a large group of products and services, during periods where the market exchange rate may, on average, equate purchasing power, the prices of the individual products and services or small groups of products and services need not equate.
This Economic Insights article is based on Economic Analysis Division research into U.S.–Canadian price differences. For more information, see:
Baldwin, J.R., and R. Macdonald. 2009. PPPs: Purchasing Power or Producing Power Parities? Statistics Canada Catalogue no.11F0027M. Ottawa, Ontario. Economic Analysis Research Paper Series. No. 058.
Baldwin, J. R., W. Gu and B. Yan. 2008. Relative Multifactor Productivity Levels in Canada and the United States: A Sectoral Analysis. Statistics Canada Catalogue no. 15-206-X. Ottawa, Ontario. The Canadian Productivity Review. No. 19.
Baldwin, J.R., and B. Yan. 2006. Domestic and Foreign Influences on Canadian Prices over Exchange Rate Cycles, 1974 to 1996. Statistics Canada Catalogue no. 11F0027M. Ottawa, Ontario. Economic Analysis Research Paper Series. No. 43.
- Date modified: